star (2012-06-30)
Przytoczę może jeszcze pozytywną opinię krytyki z K&L Wines:


92 points Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
A beautiful wine and one of my favorites from this estate, this blend of nearly two-thirds Cabernet Sauvignon and one-third Merlot is aging impressively. Dense ruby/purple in color, with creme de cassis, charcoal, and sweet leathery and chocolatey notes intermixed with the classic Pauillac cedar and spice box, the wine is medium to full-bodied, fleshy, with sweet tannin and a long finish. It seems to have inched into its window of full drinking maturity, and will stay there for 10-15+ years. (6/ 2010)

91 points Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar
Medium-deep red-ruby. Aromatic nose combines cassis, minerals, mint, shoe polish and sexy oak. Suave and atypically showy for a recently bottled Clerc-Milon. This has lovely racy cassis and mineral flavors, a smooth texture and attractively restrained sweetness. Finishes aromatic and long, with thoroughly ripe tannins. (6/ 2003)

91 points Wine Spectator
Super aromas of currants, mineral and exotic fruits. Full-bodied, with very firm tannins. This is long and chewy. Tough Clerc, but textbook Pauillac. Cab city. (3/ 2003)

K&L Notes
33% merlot and 67% cabernet sauvignon. 30% new oak. Black raspberry flavors. This wine is round and fat. Tannins are hidden by fabulous ripe fruit flavors. Excellent balance. Should also be a fine value and long-term cellar candidate.

Widać, że odmiany inaczej wyglądają niż w 2009. Pytanie skąd je Wein-r wtedy przy okazji 2009 wziął? Kontra do tłumaczenia dla... Temiego?
wino13690#42183

wein-r (2012-06-30) Ocena: 7
Kupione w PWW (a nie CW) w 2005 za 240.
wino13690#42187

star (2012-06-30) Ocena: 8
Skopiowałem z 2009 to Centrum Wina, bo oni zaczęli sprowadzać bordoszczaki en primeur chyba, ale zamieniam na Piwnicę Wybornych Win i dopisuję cenę. Pewno w sklepach Fine Wine & Spirits. Bordeaux też w Winkolekcji pewno do kupienia, także en primeur. No i klasyki jak la Vinoteheque pewno. Dzięki Wein-r! Odpłacę się kiedyś pięknym za nadobne;-) I to nie będzie seria Prioratów ani Orvieto;-)

A co do Clerc Milon to jak zwykle oprócz baronowej strony bpdr.fr, Wine Doctor raczy nas opowieściami o 2000 pisząc jako kuszącym nad wyraz: Château Clerc-Milon (Pauillac) 2000: Dense and very vibrant and youthful colour. Such youthful exuberance on the nose too - lots of unabsorbed new oak giving coffee and toffee flavours, with flashy black fruits. Creamy, mouthfilling, full, textured and sweet. Truly a very impressive wine. Massive smooth fruit, with a toffee edge. Wonderfully seductive. Give it a decade at the very least. 18+/20 (January 2005).
wino13690#42189